Electronic Portfolios: A New Idea in Assessment
Anna Maria D. Lankes
Teachers and administrators are showing increased interest in becoming part of a "new wave" of assessment in the classroom; assessment which includes authentic and performance-based measures. These methods of assessment allow students to demonstrate desired performance through real-life situations (Meyer, 1992). Such methods of assessment a re not limited to multiple-choice and standardized tests, but include projects which require students to demonstrate their problem-solving skills as well as their skills in analyzing and synthesizing information. Several school districts across the United States have reported improved student performance associated with new assessment programs (Herman, 1992). Many schools are developing new methods for measuring students' progress in both the elementary and secondary classroom. One of these new assessment measures, the portfolio, has become increasingly popular, and technology is helping with its creation and management.
What is a Portfolio?
A portfolio at the K-12 education level is essentially a collection of a student's work which can be used to demonstrate his or her skills and accomplishments. An educational portfolio is more than just a group of projects and papers stored in a file folder. It includes other features such as teachers' evaluations and student self-reflections. According to the Northwest Evaluation Association, a portfolio is "a purposeful collection of student work that exhibits the student's efforts, progress, and achievements. The collection must include student participation in selecting contents, the criteria for selection, the criteria for judging merit, and evidence of student self-reflection" (Paulson, Paulson, & Meyer, 1991). A portfolio may be used to demonstrate a student's achievements in specific subject areas such as mathematics and science or it may be used across th e curriculum to assess abilities in all subject areas.
Why use a Portfolio?
A teacher who is interested in documenting a student's improvements in writing or mathematics throughout a school year can have the student keep a developmental portfolio containing samples of the student's work along with self-evaluations of specific assignments. Such a portfolio provides specific documentation which can be used for student evaluations and parent conferences.
Teachers may use an existing portfolio system in order to receive information about an incoming class of students. The teacher may gain a better understanding of the ability levels of his or her students prior to the start of the school year and plan accordingly.
Central Park East Secondary School in New York City uses portfolios as a means for determining graduation eligibility. Students at this school are required to complete fourteen portfolios which demonstrate their competence and performance in areas such as science and technology, ethics and social issues, community service, and history (Gold & Lanzoni, 1993).
A showcase portfolio can document a student's best work accomplished during an entire educati onal career. It can include the research papers, art work, and science experiments which best represent the student's skills and abilities.
Employment skills portfolios.
Businesses across the country are increasingly interested in viewing student portfolios in order to evaluate a prospective employee's work readiness skills. Students in the Michigan public schools, for example, are creating employability skills portfolios to demonstrate their skills to prospective employers (Stemmer, Brown, & Smith, 1992).
College admission portfolios.
Colleges and universities are using showcase portfolios to determine eligibility for admission. By requiring portfolios from prospective students, college or university admissions officers are better able to assess applicants' potential for success at their institutions.
Technology and the Creation of Computer-Based Portfolios
How to store and manage portfolio materials is a concern shared by many educators interested in implementing portfolio programs. In order to keep portfolios which would include papers, projects, and video and audio tapes for a class of students for 13 years (K-12), a school would need several additional classrooms to store this wealth of information. Many educators have been reluctant to imple ment portfolio assessment programs in their schools because of storage concerns like these. A likely solution to this problem is the creation and storage of portfolios using computer technology.
The terms "computer-based portfolio" and "electronic portfolio" are used to describe portfolios saved in electronic format. Electronic portfolios contain the same types of information as the portfolios discussed earlier, but the information is collected, stored, and managed electronically. Since current technology allows for the capture and storage of information in the form of text, graphics, sound, and video, students can save writing samples, solutions to mathematics problems, samples of art work, science projects and multimedia presentations in one coher ent document. A single computer with a large storage capacity can store portfolios for all of the students in a class. With more students creating multimedia projects, however, a floppy or even a hard disk might not suffice for storage. An alternative is to store student portfolios on a CD-ROM (a compact disk which stores text, sound, graphics and video). A CD-ROM can store approximately 650 MB of information or 300,000 sheets of typed text. This might include all of the portfolios for an entire grade level of students. A computer-based portfolio program also allows for easy transfer of information. An individual computer disk or CD-ROM could be created to transport a student's documents from teacher to teacher or school to school.
Solutions and Examples
There are several commercially available portfolio programs which offer teachers the ability to track student achievement. Aurbach's Grady Profile is one program which provides a template for teachers and students to enter work samples. Programs may include writing samples, standardized test scores, oral communication skills, and mathematics assessments. Other software programs, such as Roger Wagner Publishing's HyperStudio and Claris' FileMaker Pro, allow teachers to create their own templates for portfolio assessment. Educators can use these programs to customize portfolios to suit the needs of their classes. For example, one high school English portfolio might include outlines and drafts for each writing assignment, while another might include only the finished product along with self-reflections by the student.
One school which is involved in creating electronic portfolios for all its students is East Syracuse-Minoa High School in East Syracuse, New York. Students at this high school are creating electronic portfolios which can be sent to colleges as part of the admissions process and to potential employers to determine workplace readiness. This electronic portfolio, called "The Portfolio Manger," was created in HyperStudio and contains t raditional information about students (transcripts, letters of recommendation, and work history) as well as student-selected work samples (writing samples, multimedia research papers, art work, and video clips from a performance in the school play). The students are responsible for updating and selecting the work samples they include in the portfolio and can select virtually any piece of work that they believe best represents their skills and abilities. Currently, students begin creating portfolios during their sophomore year and continue updating and revising the work samples throughout their high school careers. Upon completion, the portfolio can be distributed in computer disk, CD-ROM, video tape, or print versions.
The implementation of computer-based portfolios for student assessment is an exciting educational innovation. This method of assessment not only offers an authentic demonstration of accomplishments, but also allows students to take responsibility for the work they have done. In turn, this motivates them to accomplish more in the future. A computer-based portfolio system offers many advantages for both the education and the business communities and should continue to be a popular assessment tool in the "information age."
Alternative assessment and technology. (1993). ERIC Digest. ERIC Clearinghouse on Information & Technology, Syracuse, NY. (ED 365 312)
Barrett, H. C. (1994). Technology-supported assessment portfolios. Computing Teacher, 21(6), 9-12. (EJ 479 843)
Brewer, G. (1994). FileMaker Pro [Computer program]. Santa Clara, CA: Claris Corporation.
Gold, J. (Producer & Director), & Lanzoni, M. (Ed). (1993). Graduation by portfolio--Central Park East Secondary School [Videotape]. New York: Post Production, 29th Street Video Inc.
Grady, M. P. (1991). Grady Profile [Computer program]. St. Louis, MO: Aurbach & Associates, Inc.
Herman, J. L. (1992). What research tells us about good assessment. Educational Leadership, 49(8), 74-78. (EJ 444 324)
Hunter, B. & Other s. (1993).Technology in the classroom: Preparing students for the information age. Schools in the Middle, 2(4), 3-6. (EJ 465 259)
McLellan, H. (1993). Evaluation in a situated learning environment. Educational Technology, 33(3), 39-45. (EJ 461 596)
Meye r, C. A.(1992). What's the difference between "authentic" and "performance" assessment? Educational Leadership, 49(8), 39-40. (EJ 444 312)
Paulson, L. F., Paulson P. R., & Meyer C. (1991). What makes a portfolio a portfolio? Educational Leadership, 48(5 ), 60-63. (EJ 421 352)
Saylor, K. & Overton, J. (1993). Kentucky writing and math portfolios. Middlesboro, KY: Middlesboro Intermediate School. (ED 361 382)
Stemmer, P., Brown, B., & Smith, C. (1992). The employability skills portfolio. Educational Leadership, 49(6), 32-35. (EJ 441 170)
Wagner, R. (1993). HyperStudio [Computer program]. El Cajon, CA: Roger Wagner Publishing, Inc.
* * * * * * * *
This ERIC Digest was prepared by Anna Maria D. Lankes, Systems Consultant-Computer Assisted Instruction, OCM BOCES, Thompson Road, Syracuse, NY.; firstname.lastname@example.org
ERIC Digests are in the public domain and may be freely reproduced and disseminated.
ERIC Clearinghouse on Information & Technology, Syracuse University, 4-194 Center for Science & Technology, Syracuse, New York 13244-4100; (315) 443-3640; (800) 464-9107; Fax: (315) 443-5448; Internet: email@example.com
This publication was prepared with funding from the Office of Educational Research and Improvement, U.S. Department of Education, under contract no. RR93002009. The opinions expressed in this report do not necessarily reflect the positions of OERI or ED.